Welcome to McVeytown Original Italian Pizza
Nestled in the heart of McVeytown, PA, McVeytown Original Italian Pizza is a beloved gem renowned for its authentic Italian flavors. The eatery excels in crafting mouth-watering pizzas and delectable subs, ensuring every bite is fresh and flavorful. Customers rave about the friendly atmosphere and attentive staff, making it a perfect spot for both dine-in and takeout. Signature dishes like the BBQ chicken sub and classic cheese pizza stand out for their rich taste and quality ingredients. Whether you’re recuperating after an outdoor adventure or enjoying a family night, McVeytown Original Italian Pizza promises a satisfying dining experience.
- 1 John St, Mcveytown, PA 17051, United States Hotline: +1 717-899-7133
Welcome to McVeytown Original Italian Pizza, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Mcveytown, Pennsylvania. Located at 1 John St, this charming restaurant has quickly established itself as a local favorite. Known for its authentic Italian offerings, McVeytown OIP not only serves up delicious pizza but also a variety of mouth-watering subs and delectable sides.
The moment you step inside, you are greeted by the warm ambiance and friendly staff, making it clear that customer service is a priority here. One reviewer, Nikki Goss, raves about the amazing food and friendly staff, with hot and delicious orders every time. As she notes, it's her go-to place even on Sundays, which is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to accessibility and service.
McVeytown Original Italian Pizza prides itself on the quality of its ingredients. The reviews reflect a deep appreciation for the flavors that the kitchen delivers. Jeremy Weaver highlights the sensational Philly cheesesteak pizza, stating its quality as something he would gladly order again. Meanwhile, William Markle expresses how the taste lingers long after you’ve savored your slice — a true mark of exceptional pizza. Furthermore, Todd Graff claims the chicken Parm sandwich was a delightful post-hike reward, showcasing the restaurant's versatility in catering to various tastes.
Another aspect that sets McVeytown Original Italian Pizza apart is its dedication to accommodating a variety of dietary preferences, demonstrated by Kenneth Stauffer’s positive experience with the gluten-free pizza options. Each dish is crafted with care, topped with fresh and flavorful ingredients that reflect an old-school cooking philosophy, as je br points out in their glowing review.
Whether you choose to dine in or opt for takeout, like Jrd Lewistown did after a long day, the experience remains delightful. The staff's pleasant demeanor combined with the flavorsome dishes ensure that every visit is memorable. McVeytown Original Italian Pizza is not just a restaurant; it’s a community staple where delicious food and amiable service create a perfect recipe for success.
For anyone in the area or just passing through, I highly recommend stopping by McVeytown Original Italian Pizza. You won't just walk away satisfied; you'll be planning your next visit before you even finish eating!
For more information or to place an order, give them a call at +1 717-899-7133. Come hungry, leave happy!

Food and staff are always amazing. My favorite place to get a sub love that they're open on Sundays. Staff is friendly and my orders have always been right and the food is always been hot and delicious

An absolutely amazing restaurant! BBQ chicken sub was tender, full of meat, and mouth-watering! Pizza was made the way old school OIPs used to make them! Toppings were fresh and flavorful! Will definitely be returning!

If you travel or live close please enjoy the flavors, you eat a slice of pizza here and still taste it (and it's good) an hour later. It was the same when I had house salad. This has to be the best restaurant that I know of.

Nice pizza place! Came here after a 9.77 mile hike at the Thousand Steps and Shorbs Summit. Had a chicken Parm sandwich, and it was very good. Sub rolls looked like they were fresh made as well.

We were traveling home from Raystown Lake and stopped at this little pizza shop. My husband ordered a GF personal pizza w/mushroom and onions and I ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza. Pizza was delicious and service was great!! Very friendly staff!!

We worked all day and then went to enjoy our grandsons football game. Neither one of us felt like cooking, so a quick call to the OIP and supper would be ready in a few minutes. Everyone was wonderful, very pleasant and we enjoyed the conversation. We left with our food and enjoyed it at home. We eat in and get takeout, either way, you can't go wrong with MCVEYTOWN OIP !

The Philly cheese stake pizza was very good definitely will buy it again!

Food was delicious, hot and reasonably priced! The owner and waitress were super nice too! Highly recommend!